- Privacy
- Terms
- Stay Connected
The morning sun illuminates the stark beauty of Ajo’s landscape, casting long shadows across the open-pit mine that dominates the eastern edge of town. Unlike many of Arizona’s mining communities that flared briefly before fading into ghost towns, Ajo represents a different story—one of remarkable persistence through boom and bust cycles. Nestled in the Sonoran Desert of southwestern Arizona, approximately 43 miles from the Mexican border, this community still stands as a living testament to Arizona’s mining heritage, though much diminished from its heyday. The town’s Spanish name, meaning “garlic” (though some argue it derives from a Tohono O’odham word for paint), reflects the cultural crossroads where Anglo, Mexican, and Native American influences have converged for generations.
Beyond the brutal circumstances of their deaths and burial, John Tewksbury Jr. and William Jacobs represent the human cost of frontier conflicts. Tewksbury was a young married man whose wife Eva was about to give birth when he was killed. His death left her a widow with a newborn child in an environment where survival demanded hard physical labor and mutual support—both in short supply for the bereaved wife of a feud victim.
Less is known about William Jacobs, though records indicate he was a friend of the Tewksburys and associated with sheep interests in the area. His death demonstrates how the violence of the Pleasant Valley War extended beyond the core family members to engulf friends, allies, and associates on both sides. The fact that he shares a grave with John Tewksbury Jr. has linked their names in history, though Jacobs might otherwise have faded from historical memory.
Eva Tewksbury’s actions in the aftermath of the killings—emerging from the besieged cabin with a shovel to bury her husband despite the danger—speaks to the remarkable resilience of frontier women. Her gesture carried such moral weight that even the gunmen who had killed her husband temporarily ceased fire, recognizing some boundary of human decency that should not be crossed even in the midst of a blood feud. This moment of respect for mourning rituals amid otherwise unrestrained violence offers a glimpse into the complex ethical codes that operated on the frontier.
| Category | Details |
|---|---|
| Conflict Name | Pleasant Valley War (aka Tewksbury-Graham Feud) |
| Time Period | Circa 1882–1892 |
| Location | Pleasant Valley, centered around Young, Arizona |
| Main Families Involved | Tewksbury (mixed-race cattle/sheep ranchers) and Graham (Anglo cattle ranchers) |
| Other Names Mentioned | Jacobs may refer to associates or ranch hands aligned with Tewksburys |
| Cause of Feud | Tensions over cattle vs. sheep ranching, racial prejudice, land rights, water access, and rustling accusations |
| Notable Characteristics | Exceptionally violent and personal; involved assassinations, ambushes, and revenge killings |
| Death Toll Estimate | 20 to 50+ individuals, possibly more |
| Key Turning Point | Murder of John Tewksbury Jr. and William Jacobs in 1887 |
| Legal Aftermath | Limited arrests and convictions; law enforcement had little control |
| Outcome | Near-total annihilation of the Graham family; Tewksbury survivors left area |
| Cultural Impact | Inspired books, articles, and Western lore; one of the bloodiest family feuds in U.S. history |
| Modern Legacy | Young, AZ features historical markers, cemetery with feud victims, and occasional reenactments or tours |
| Nearby Historical Sites | Young Cemetery, Pleasant Valley Schoolhouse, and Tewksbury family sites |
The shared grave of John Tewksbury Jr. and William Jacobs represents one of the most poignant and disturbing chapters in what came to be known as the Pleasant Valley War or Tonto Basin War—a decade-long blood feud that raged between the cattle-ranching Grahams and the sheep-herding Tewksburys from 1882 to 1892. While many frontier conflicts pitted cattlemen against sheepherders, this particular vendetta stands out for its extraordinary violence and the near-complete annihilation of both families involved.
The origins of the conflict remain somewhat murky, as is often the case with feuds that occur in sparsely populated areas with limited documentation. What began as tensions over grazing rights, water access, and accusations of cattle rustling escalated into a series of retaliatory killings that would claim between 20 and 50 lives, depending on which historical accounts are believed. The feud was so brutal and extensive that it reportedly delayed Arizona’s bid for statehood, as eastern politicians pointed to it as evidence that the territory was too lawless for self-governance. Arizona would not achieve statehood until 1912, decades after the conflict ended.
The Tewksbury family, headed by James D. Tewksbury, had established their ranch in Pleasant Valley in the early 1880s. James and his sons—John Jr., Jim, Ed, and Frank—ran cattle before becoming involved with sheep interests, a move that inflamed existing tensions with neighboring cattle ranchers. The Graham brothers—Tom and John—had actually been invited to the area by Ed Tewksbury, a decision that would prove tragically misguided as the families eventually became mortal enemies.
The Tewksbury-Jacobs grave site sits on what was once Tewksbury family land, located in Section 10, Township 8 North, Range 14E on the Tonto map. Visitors today must follow a dirt road to a fence line and then walk approximately half a mile to reach the actual grave site. Unlike more elaborate pioneer cemeteries, this is a single, simple grave marking the spot where two victims of frontier violence were hastily buried where they fell.
The site’s remoteness has preserved it from vandalism and excessive visitation, though this same isolation makes it challenging to access. The grave is not marked on newer maps of the area, reflecting both its relative obscurity and the sensitivity surrounding sites associated with the Pleasant Valley War. Despite this, the location remains an important historical landmark for those studying Arizona’s territorial period and the violent conflicts that characterized the settling of the American West.
Today, the site consists of a modest marker identifying the final resting place of these two men. The surrounding landscape has changed little since the 1880s, allowing visitors to experience something close to the environmental context in which these tragic events unfolded. The nearby location of the old J.D. Tewksbury cabin, where family members were reportedly pinned down during the attack, adds to the historical significance of the area.
The events leading to the deaths of John Tewksbury Jr. and William Jacobs represent one of the most brutal episodes in the Pleasant Valley War. On a September morning in 1887, members of the Graham faction, including Tom and John Graham and several of their supporters, positioned themselves in ambush near the Tewksbury cabin. As John Tewksbury Jr. and his friend William Jacobs emerged from the cabin to gather their horses, the hidden gunmen opened fire, killing both men instantly.
What followed has become one of the most infamous incidents in Arizona frontier history. According to multiple historical accounts, after killing the two men, the Graham faction continued firing at the Tewksbury cabin for hours, effectively pinning down the other family members inside, including John’s pregnant wife, Eva. Meanwhile, in a particularly gruesome development, the bodies of Tewksbury and Jacobs were left where they had fallen.
For days—some accounts say as many as eleven—the bodies remained exposed to the elements and wildlife. Most disturbing were reports that feral hogs began to devour the corpses while armed members of the Graham faction prevented anyone from recovering and burying the bodies. This deliberate desecration represented the extreme depths of hatred that had developed between the feuding families.
Eventually, according to frontier lore, Eva Tewksbury, who was eight and a half months pregnant at the time, emerged from the cabin with a shovel. In a moment that speaks to the complex codes of honor that existed even amid such violence, the shooting temporarily ceased while she dug shallow graves for her husband and his friend. The firing resumed once she returned to the cabin, but no further deaths occurred that day.
When Justice of the Peace John Meadows finally arrived with Charles Perkins to conduct an inquest and properly bury the dead, they found a grisly scene. After so many days exposed to the elements and wildlife, the bodies were in an advanced state of decomposition and had been partially consumed by feral hogs. The condition of the remains made conventional burial impossible.
Charles Perkins later described the horrific task they faced: the bodies could not be moved intact, as decomposition had advanced too far. All they could do was dig shallow graves where the men had fallen and roll the remains into them using shovels, unable to provide the dignified burial that frontier custom normally demanded. This shared grave, born of necessity rather than design, has linked Tewksbury and Jacobs in death as they were in life—victims of the same violence, buried together in the same soil.
On September 10, 1887, Justice of the Peace John Meadows conducted a formal inquest into the deaths. The jury, which included men who had been with the Tewksburys during the siege, concluded that Tewksbury and Jacobs had been killed by “parties unknown,” despite widespread knowledge of who was responsible. This outcome reflected the complicated reality of frontier justice, where formal legal processes often failed to address violence that everyone understood but few would officially acknowledge.
The Tewksbury-Jacobs grave differs significantly from the formal community cemeteries that developed in more established settlements. Unlike the planned burial grounds in Young (formerly Pleasant Valley) or other Arizona pioneer towns, this isolated grave was created out of immediate necessity at the site of death. It represents emergency burial practices rather than organized community memorialization.
The grave’s isolation stands in contrast to the patterns of burial seen in community cemeteries, where family plots, religious sections, and some degree of organization reflected the social structures of living communities. The Young Cemetery, which contains the remains of many other victims of the Pleasant Valley War, exemplifies the more formalized approach to burial that developed as settlements matured and established permanent institutions.
The contrast between this isolated grave and community burial grounds speaks to the chaotic and violent circumstances that prevented normal mourning rituals from taking place. In settled communities, death typically involved community gathering, religious ceremony, and proper burial in designated grounds. The crude interment of Tewksbury and Jacobs shows how completely the normal social fabric had been torn by the feud.
Coverage of the killings of Tewksbury and Jacobs appeared in regional newspapers, providing some of the few contemporary accounts of these events. The Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner carried an article titled “More Blood” in its September 14, 1887 issue, describing the ambush and noting that Sheriff Mulvenon believed Tewksbury had returned home to be with his wife, who was about to give birth.
The Arizona Silver Belt also reported on the incident, specifically mentioning that the bodies had lain where they fell for eleven days before burial. These newspaper accounts, while often sensationalized or influenced by partisan sympathies, provide crucial historical documentation of events that might otherwise be known only through oral tradition or family memories.
Regional newspapers played an important role in shaping public perception of the Pleasant Valley War. By reporting on the violence—often in graphic detail—they both informed distant readers about events in this remote area and contributed to the territory’s reputation for lawlessness. This reputation would later be cited as a reason to delay Arizona’s admission to statehood, demonstrating the broader political consequences of the feud.
The remote location of the Tewksbury-Jacobs grave site highlights the isolation that characterized much of Arizona Territory during this period. Unlike communities that developed along railroad lines and benefited from the connectivity they provided, Pleasant Valley remained difficult to access, reached only by rough wagon roads that became impassable in bad weather.
This isolation contributed to the intensity and duration of the Pleasant Valley War. Law enforcement officials from county seats or territorial offices faced arduous journeys to investigate incidents or arrest suspects. News traveled slowly, allowing violence to escalate before outside authorities could intervene. The absence of railroads also meant that the area remained economically marginalized, increasing competition for limited resources like grazing land and water—key factors in the initial disputes between the Tewksburys and Grahams.
The contrast between connected railroad towns and isolated settlements like those in Pleasant Valley reveals how transportation infrastructure shaped patterns of development and governance across the territory. Communities along rail lines generally developed more robust institutions, including formal cemeteries, while remote areas relied more heavily on informal justice and improvised responses to death, as evidenced by the Tewksbury-Jacobs burial.
The killings of Tewksbury and Jacobs marked one of the bloodiest phases of the Pleasant Valley War, but they did not end the conflict. Over the next several years, violence continued as members of both factions were killed in ambushes, shootouts, and even legal executions. By 1892, only two adult men from the feuding families remained alive: Tom Graham and Ed Tewksbury.
The final act of the decades-long vendetta occurred on August 2, 1892, when Tom Graham was shot from ambush near Tempe, Arizona, far from the original conflict zone. Before dying, Graham identified Ed Tewksbury as his killer, a claim supported by witnesses. Tewksbury was arrested and tried twice for the murder—the first trial resulted in a hung jury, while the second ended in a conviction that was later set aside on a legal technicality. In 1895, the case was dismissed entirely.
Edwin Tewksbury, the last survivor of the Pleasant Valley War, lived until April 1904, when he died in Globe, Arizona. His death marked the end of living memory of the conflict that had claimed so many lives, including those of John Tewksbury Jr. and William Jacobs in their shared grave.
Today, the Tewksbury-Jacobs grave site serves as a tangible reminder of one of the most violent episodes in Western American history. Unlike romanticized depictions of frontier conflicts in popular culture, this simple grave speaks to the brutal reality of a feud that destroyed families and traumatized a community.
The site has historical significance as a rare example of a documented battlefield burial from a civilian conflict. While military battlefields often include marked graves or formal cemeteries, civilian violence typically left fewer such traces on the landscape. The preservation of this grave, along with documented accounts of the circumstances surrounding it, provides valuable insights for historians studying frontier violence and burial practices.
The Pleasant Valley War has inspired numerous historical studies, novels, and films, including Zane Grey’s 1922 novel “To the Last Man,” which was based on the feud. Grey reportedly found that even decades after the events, local residents were reluctant to discuss the conflict, demonstrating the deep psychological impact it had on the community. This reluctance to speak about the feud contributed to the various contradictory accounts that make definitive historical reconstruction challenging.
The Tewksbury-Jacobs grave site poses unique conservation challenges due to its remote location and the simple nature of the original burial. Unlike formal cemeteries with permanent markers and regular maintenance, this isolated grave relies on historical memory and occasional visitors to ensure its continued recognition.
Conservation efforts must balance preservation with respect for the site’s historical authenticity. Too much development or visitation could damage the environmental context that helps visitors understand the isolation and vulnerability of the original settlement. At the same time, without some form of protection and interpretation, the significance of the site might be lost to future generations.
The grave’s inclusion in historical registers and documentation by projects like the Arizona Pioneer & Cemetery Research Project helps ensure that even if the physical marker eventually deteriorates, the historical record of this significant site will be maintained. This documentation is particularly important given the controversy and multiple interpretations surrounding the Pleasant Valley War.
Visitors to the Tewksbury-Jacobs grave should approach the site with respect for both its historical significance and its nature as a burial place. The remote location requires preparation, including appropriate vehicles, water, and navigation tools. Visitors should stay on established paths, avoid disturbing any artifacts or features, and remember that they are visiting a place where real people died under tragic circumstances.
The site can be reached by following directions to Section 10, Township 8 North, Range 14E on the Tonto map, though visitors should be aware that more recent maps may not mark the grave specifically. The dirt road access requires careful navigation, and walking is necessary for the final approach to the grave site.
Those interested in the broader context of the Pleasant Valley War can also visit the Young Cemetery, where other participants in the feud are buried, and the Pioneer Living History Museum in Phoenix, which houses the relocated cabin of John Tewksbury Sr., complete with gun ports that reflect the dangerous environment in which these frontier families lived.
The shared grave of John Tewksbury Jr. and William Jacobs stands as a stark reminder of the violence that sometimes accompanied the settlement of the American West. Unlike romanticized tales of frontier justice, the circumstances of their deaths and burial reveal the brutal reality of a feud that destroyed families and left deep scars on a community.
As visitors stand at this isolated grave site today, they connect with a moment when the thin veneer of civilization gave way to primal violence—when two men were killed and left for wild animals, when a pregnant widow had to bury her own husband with a shovel, and when neighbors became mortal enemies over disputes about land, livestock, and honor.
In this remote corner of Arizona, where the wind still whispers through the same junipers and pines that witnessed the violence of 1887, the Tewksbury-Jacobs grave invites us to contemplate the complex legacy of the American frontier—its promise and opportunity shadowed by conflict and bloodshed. Their story, preserved in this humble burial place, reminds us that the pioneering spirit so celebrated in American mythology often came with a terrible human cost.